Ícaro Iasbeck
Frameworks and methodologies

A business case for finance: the page the CFO approves

The client's finance director decides the purchase by reading one page, usually with no salesperson in the room. The blocks that page needs, the language finance speaks, an illustrative example with two scenarios and how to prepare the champion to carry the document through approval.

13 min read

The client’s CFO approves a purchase when they find, on one page, how much cash goes out and in which months, how much comes back and from when, which assumptions support the return and who on their side validated them, and how much it costs to delay the decision. They usually read this document with no salesperson in the room, forwarded by the internal champion, and decide in a few minutes whether they trust the numbers. If you run sales, your decision is to make this page a team standard: every deal above a defined size reaches negotiation with a one-page business case, built with the client, reviewed by the manager and written in the language of finance. The 30-slide deck with a four-digit ROI stays out.

When I review proposals from sales teams, the business case shows up in two formats that do not work. In the first, the salesperson attaches a marketing ROI calculator, with market averages and a return no finance team takes seriously. In the second, they write three pages about features and put the investment on the last line, without saying in which month the money goes out. In both cases the champion takes the document to the CFO, hears the first question (“where did this number come from?”) and cannot answer. The deal comes back to the salesperson with a discount request, because the discount is the only variable finance managed to understand.

What does a CFO look for in a purchase proposal?

Finance reads the proposal as a competition for cash. Money that goes to your solution stops going to another project, and the CFO compares your request with the others on their desk. In a Gartner survey released in 2025, conducted in August of that year with more than 200 CFOs, 56% placed enterprise-wide cost optimization among their top five priorities for 2026, and 51% included improving the accuracy of financial forecasts on the same list. A finance director with those goals looks for two things on your page: whether the purchase cuts cost or protects revenue in a way they can measure, and whether the assumptions are solid enough for them to put the number in the year’s projection.

The page also has to survive the committee. In its report The State Of Business Buying, Forrester, in 2026, counts 13 internal stakeholders and nine external influencers in a typical buying decision, and identifies procurement as a decision-maker in 53% of B2B buying cycles. The business case circulates among these people, and each one reads the part that concerns them. The map of who takes part is in B2B buying committee.

What is a one-page business case?

It is the financial summary of the decision, written for whoever approves the money. It differs from the sales proposal, which describes scope, timeline and terms, and from the calculation spreadsheet, which holds the math and the sources. The page sits in between: it carries the numbers the spreadsheet calculates and the decision the proposal asks for, without detailing either. How to build the numbers with the client (cost of the problem, expected gain, full investment, payback period and risks) is in B2B negotiation with ROI. Here I deal with the format that reaches finance.

The one-page limit forces the salesperson to choose. The CFO needs to see the decision, the money and the risk, and whatever does not fit goes into the appendix.

Which blocks does the page for finance need?

I use seven blocks, in the order finance tends to ask.

Block CFO’s question What to write Common mistake
Decision requested What do you want me to approve? Option, total amount, contract term, decision date Opening with the supplier’s story
Problem and current cost How much does this cost us today? Monthly cost of the problem, with the internal source for each number Using a market average instead of the client’s data
Cash outlay How much goes out, and when? License, implementation, internal hours, switching cost, by month or quarter Showing only the license
Return in two scenarios How much comes back, and from when? Conservative and expected, with the month the gain starts A single, optimistic scenario
Payback How long until I get the money back? Payback month in each scenario Showing a percentage ROI with no time frame
Assumptions and owners Who stands behind these numbers? A short list of assumptions with the name of the area that validated them An assumption with no owner
Cost of delay What happens if I leave it for next year? Gain lost per month of delay Commercial deadline pressure with no number

The assumptions block is the one the CFO reads most carefully. A sentence like “30% reduction in rework, estimated by the operations coordinator based on tickets from August to October” says where the number came from and who answers for it. If the assumption comes from the supplier, finance will discount it in their head.

An illustrative one-page business case

The numbers below are hypothetical and serve to show the structure. Imagine a distributor that loses orders and redoes work in the handoff between sales and logistics, with a cost estimated by its own operation at R$ 60 thousand per month. The proposed solution costs R$ 120 thousand in licenses in the first year, R$ 80 thousand in implementation and 400 internal hours, which the client’s finance team valued at R$ 40 thousand. The first-year outlay adds up to R$ 240 thousand, and implementation takes three months, so the gain starts in month four.

Item Conservative scenario Expected scenario
First-year outlay R$ 240 thousand R$ 240 thousand
Reduction in the cost of the problem 30% 50%
Monthly gain from month 4 R$ 18 thousand R$ 30 thousand
Accumulated gain in the first year (9 months) R$ 162 thousand R$ 270 thousand
Payback month for the initial outlay Month 17 Month 11
Cost of delaying the decision by six months R$ 108 thousand R$ 180 thousand

In the expected scenario, eight months of gain (from the fourth to the eleventh) add up to the R$ 240 thousand outlay. In the conservative one, it takes 14 months of gain, and payback comes in month 17. The page does not hide that, in the conservative scenario, the first year closes negative, and that transparency helps the CFO trust the rest. The cost of delay multiplies each scenario’s monthly gain by six.

Finance will also ask how the expense fits into the budget. An annual license is usually an operating expense, and some implementation projects may be treated differently by the client’s accounting. The salesperson does not decide this: they ask the champion how finance classifies this type of spending and whether there is money set aside in next year’s budget.

How do you speak finance’s language?

Salespeople and finance use different words for the same things, and the translation changes how the page is read.

Salespeople tend to write Finance reads better Why
“Investment of R$ 200 thousand” “Outlay of R$ 240 thousand in year 1, of which R$ 40 thousand in internal hours” The CFO counts internal cost even if the salesperson does not
“300% ROI” “Payback in month 11 in the expected scenario and month 17 in the conservative one” Payback period says more than a percentage with no time frame
“Productivity increase” “R$ 30 thousand less per month in rework, measured in tickets” A gain with no monetary unit does not go into the projection
“Special terms until Friday” “Each month of delay postpones R$ 30 thousand in gains” Commercial pressure annoys, opportunity cost convinces
“A similar client saved 40%” “30% assumption validated by the operations coordinator” A third party’s result does not count as an assumption

If the client’s company has an internal investment approval model, with a hurdle rate, a maximum payback period or its own form, ask the champion for it before writing. Filling in the format the CFO already knows saves a round of questions and shows that the supplier understands how the company decides.

How does the champion take the page through approval?

The champion is the person at the client who wants the solution and will defend the business case in the meetings the salesperson does not attend. Besides the page, they need three things: answers to the questions the CFO will ask, the supporting spreadsheet with the sources and the confidence of someone who has rehearsed the conversation.

  1. Write the page with the champion. The assumptions come from them and from the colleagues they point to. When the CFO asks “where did this come from?”, they answer with the name of an area in their own company.
  2. Validate the numbers with whoever answers for them. A 20-minute conversation with operations or the controller before the meeting keeps the CFO from knocking down the assumption in front of the committee.
  3. Rehearse the hard questions. The salesperson plays the CFO and asks: “what if the gain falls below the conservative scenario?”, “what happens if implementation is late?”, “why now and not in the second half?”.
  4. Agree on the approval path. Who signs, in which meeting, how far in advance the document has to arrive and whether approval levels change with the amount. This path goes into the mutual action plan.
  5. Offer to take part. The salesperson offers a 15-minute conversation with finance, without insisting. Some CFOs prefer to hear the implementation risks from the supplier directly.

This work gives shape to the economic buyer and champion items in qualification methods such as MEDDIC: who approves the money, with what criteria and who defends the purchase from the inside.

How can AI stress-test the business case before you send it?

AI plays a skeptical CFO well. It reads the page and the spreadsheet, looks for assumptions with no owner, math that does not add up and claims with no number, and returns the questions finance would probably ask. The salesperson reviews and corrects before sending it to the champion. The final math stays with the salesperson and the manager, because the model makes arithmetic mistakes and may invent an assumption to “complete” its reasoning. Check your company’s AI use policy before pasting client data.

What sinks a business case on the CFO’s desk?

An assumption from the supplier

The gain percentage the salesperson took from a case study or a market average is the first number finance throws out. If the client does not have the data, the page says so and proposes measuring it in the first months.

An incomplete outlay

Internal team hours, migration cost, training and the second-year license are often left out. The CFO adds these items up on their own, finds a number larger than the one on the page and starts to distrust everything else.

Gain stated as gross revenue

Promising higher sales without talking about margin confuses finance, which thinks in profit and cash. If the gain is revenue, the page shows the margin that revenue generates.

ROI with no time frame

A 300% return over five years and a 300% return in one year are different decisions. Payback by scenario tells the CFO when the money comes back.

A 30-day plan for leadership to adopt the standard

  1. Week 1, baseline. List the deals above the size threshold that are in negotiation and check how many have a business case, how many have assumptions validated by the client and how many received a discount request after the meeting with finance.
  2. Week 2, single template. Publish the one-page template with the seven blocks and the supporting spreadsheet, and define who reviews it before it goes out.
  3. Week 3, practice. Run a session with the manager playing the CFO, on the quarter’s real deals, with the salesperson defending the page.
  4. Week 4, routine. Add the question “has the client validated the business case?” to the pipeline meeting for deals above the threshold, and create a CRM field for the validation date.
  5. Day 30, review. Compare the share of deals with a validated business case and track, in the next cycle, the win rate and average discount for those deals.

If your leadership wants the team to build and defend the business case with the client, instead of opening the negotiation with a discount, that is the work of the in-company training on complex negotiation. The training uses the team’s open negotiations to build business cases and simulate the conversation with the CFO and the champion, and ends with two deliverables ready for the following week: the team’s objection matrix and a closing guide that includes the one-page business case template.

Frequently asked questions

What does a CFO want to see in a business case?

How much cash goes out and when, how much comes back and from when, which assumptions support the return and who validated them, and the cost of delay. All on one page, with the supporting spreadsheet attached.

What is the difference between a business case and a sales proposal?

The proposal describes scope, timeline and terms. The business case summarizes the financial decision for whoever approves the money and refers to the proposal as an attachment.

Does a business case need more than one scenario?

Yes, two are enough: conservative and expected. Showing the conservative scenario, even with the first year negative, increases finance’s trust in the numbers.

Who should write the business case, the salesperson or the client?

The salesperson writes it with the champion, and the assumptions come from areas within the client. The document the client helped build is the one they defend in the meeting with the CFO.

Should the salesperson attend the meeting with finance?

If invited, yes, for a short conversation about assumptions and risks. If not, they prepare the champion with the likely questions and answers.

How do you calculate the cost of delaying the purchase?

Multiply each scenario’s monthly gain by the number of months of delay. The number shows the CFO what the company gives up while the decision waits.

  • Business case
  • B2B negotiation
  • Value selling
  • Buying committee
From the text to practice

Want to bring this to your team?

The topics in this article also become in-company training: designed from a diagnosis of your operation, with real cases from your team and a deliverable that stays with the company.

See the training